I remember sitting in a college café with a friend—let’s call her Ayesha—when the Karnataka hijab controversy hit the headlines. She looked up from her phone, sighed, and said, “I wear the hijab because I want to. But now, suddenly, it feels like everyone has an opinion about it—except me.”
And just like that, the debate that was supposed to be about women’s empowerment became a shouting match about religion.
The Dress, the Debate, the Dilemma
Let’s get this straight: the hijab is many things to many people. For some, it’s a religious obligation. For others, it’s cultural. And yes, for some women, it’s a personal, feminist choice—an assertion of identity in a world that often objectifies women.
So when governments or institutions impose a ban on it, claiming it’s for women’s “liberation,” it raises a valid question: who decides what liberation looks like? If feminism is about choice, isn’t banning the hijab as oppressive as forcing someone to wear it?
A Selective Kind of Feminism?
Here’s what bugs me. No one blinks an eye when nuns wear veils or when brides walk down the aisle in white gowns and veils. No one questions their “freedom.” But when a Muslim girl walks into a classroom with a headscarf, suddenly it becomes a national crisis.
The hijab, unfortunately, has become a lightning rod—used not just to discuss women’s rights, but to dog-whistle communal identities. And that’s where the line between feminism and Islamophobia starts to blur.
From Campus to Courtroom
The courtroom battles over hijabs in educational institutions reflect a deeper problem: how India continues to struggle with religious expression in secular spaces. The constitution guarantees freedom of religion and the right to education. But when the two collide, who wins?
In many cases, it seems, religion is losing. But more worryingly, young girls are the ones paying the price—forced to choose between their faith and their future. That’s not liberation. That’s coercion dressed up as progress.
Whose Morality Is It Anyway?
Let’s be honest. Much of the hijab debate is fueled by discomfort—especially among those who see veiling as regressive. But that discomfort often comes from misunderstanding, not malice. The problem arises when discomfort turns into policy.
Shouldn’t we ask: are these bans really about feminism? Or are they about enforcing a homogenized idea of what a woman should look like to be considered “modern” or “educated”?
It reminds me of how in the West, Muslim women are stereotyped as oppressed unless they visibly reject their faith. It’s a strange kind of feminism that only champions women who make the “right” kind of choices.
Young Voices, Hard Choices
When you talk to Muslim girls navigating this reality, their frustration is palpable. Many don’t want to be the face of a national debate. They just want to go to school, get a degree, and live their lives. But now, everything they wear is a statement—whether they like it or not.
And while the rest of the country argues about ideology, they’re stuck fighting battles their peers don’t even have to think about.
The Double Standard Test
Ask yourself: would this ban be okay if it applied to turbans? Or crucifixes? Or a tilak on the forehead? If the answer is no, then it’s not really about uniforms or discipline—it’s about control.
True feminism doesn’t tell women what to wear. It gives them the space to decide for themselves. And true secularism doesn’t erase religion—it ensures no one is punished for practicing it peacefully.
Final Thought: Stop Talking Over the Women Involved
If there’s one takeaway from this whole saga, it’s this—listen to the women wearing the hijab. Not politicians, not TV panelists, not anonymous Twitter trolls. The women themselves.
Feminism can’t be feminism if it silences the very voices it claims to protect. And a secular country can’t call itself secular if it picks and chooses which religions get to express themselves.
So, is the hijab ban about feminism or Islamophobia? Maybe it’s both. But if we’re honest, it’s mostly about fear. Fear of difference. Fear of identity. And fear of letting women make their own choices.
Comments
Please keep comments relevant and respectful. Do not post unnecessary or offensive content.
Find This Comment Offensive
Choose your reason below and click on the Submit button. This will alert our moderators to take action.